Takeaways:

  • If a competitor could say it too, it isn’t a differentiator.
  • What you believe sets you apart may not matter much to your customers. Ask them.
  • Score yourself and your three main competitors on the factors customers care about, then ask customers whether they agree.
  • Never lay claim to a position you can’t deliver today.
  • Some of the strongest proof comes from your customers, in their own words.

Read the headline on your homepage out loud. Then read the headlines on your three closest competitors’ sites. If the four could trade places without anyone noticing, you have a positioning problem, not a wording problem.

You wouldn’t be alone. In the 2024 RedRover U.S. Middle-Market B2B Marketing Performance Study, just 24% of respondents strongly agreed that their brand positioning is different from that of their competitors.

In my book, The B2B Marketing Revolution®: A Battle Plan for Guaranteed Outcomes, I wrote that in a sea of similarities, differentiation is power. Companies that simply echo the sentiments and differentiators of others often fade into brand irrelevance. The way out isn’t a cleverer tagline. It’s a difference your customers care about, and one you can prove.

Start With What Your Customers Say

It’s natural to define your differentiator from the inside out: what your team is proudest of, what you’ve invested in, what you’d lead with on a sales call. But what you think is an important point of differentiation may not matter much to your customers. They’ll all too often just tell you.

So have someone outside your company, who is more likely to get radical candor from your customers, find out which factors they rank as most crucial to their buying decision, and why they chose you over the other firms they considered. Ask the customers who left, too. That’s Battle 2 of my 12 Battles™ Framework, and my last article on customer interviews walks through how to hear the whole story.

Put Every Claim Through Four Questions

On a recent Collective 54 podcast, I talked through a simple test for a differentiator. It has to pass all four:

  • Few or no competitors can claim it.
  • It matters to customers.
  • You can prove it.
  • It’s easy to say.

Generic claims like “quality,” “service” and “experience” tend to fail the first question, because competitors can make them, too. A claim that sounds impressive but can’t be backed up fails the third, which is the most dangerous failure of all. And a claim that’s real but either buried in jargon or difficult to believe in just a few words without further due diligence fails the fourth.

Score Yourself the Way Your Customers Would

Once you know what matters to customers, see how you really stack up. In the book, I recommend a value proposition comparison grid:

  • List the key factors that matter to your customers. These could be price, quality, service, speed of delivery or something specific to your industry. Be sure to also leverage your research to identify the pain or needs on which no one in your market is delivering – versus the tried and true factors. And better yet, anticipate their future needs and get their reaction. After all, there is truth to Henry Ford’s philosophy “If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.”
  • List your company and your three main competitors.
  • Rate each one on every factor, on a 1 to 10 scale where 10 is high.

Be honest, and check your assumptions – which is why outside counsel is advised, as we all have blind spots. Leverage each competitor’s public brand positioning to support your ratings. B2B mystery shopping can also provide interesting insights: evaluate competitors as an anonymous potential customer, or ask friends or colleagues outside your company to do it for you. Then take the grid to customers you can count on for their candor and ask what they agree and disagree with. Update it regularly, because markets evolve and competition shifts.

Where you lead on a factor customers care about, you have a candidate. Where you lag, you have work to do before you can claim it.

Don’t Claim What You Can’t Deliver Yet

In my book, I share a cautionary tale about an industrial automation company that was confident in its unbeatable differentiator: advanced technology no competitor could match. The trouble was that the technology was more of a goal than a current reality.

That positioning won contracts and pulled major customers away from competitors. Then the company lost them within months, when the technology failed to perform as promised. The reputational setback will likely take years to recover from.

The lesson: avoid laying claim to a brand position that is aspirational rather than realistic, or you risk losing the very customers it won you.

Let Your Customers Make the Case

Proof doesn’t have to be a statistic. In another case study, a manufacturer and its competitors were all touting expertise and customer service. Research uncovered something far more specific. By the time its engineering customers needed help, they were in pain: lost sales and missed targets because they didn’t have the manufacturing capacity to keep up.

So the company let its customers tell that story in their own words, through video. Its new differentiator was pain relief, and those authentic stories broke through.

Your proof might look different: overwhelming proof, commitments you keep, customers willing to say it for you, specialization, a named methodology, risk reversal, outcome pricing, selectivity in who you work with, proprietary data, or an edgy point of view. What matters is that it’s real and it’s specific.

Find the Opening, Then Move

Map your company and your competitors on the two factors that matter most to your customers, and look for the space no one owns. We did this for a commercial HVAC supply company whose customers, mostly small mom-and-pop HVAC shops, cared most about two things: how fast they could get the equipment, and how much product support and training came with it. Our client shipped fast but wasn’t doing anything on install support and training, and most of its competitors weren’t doing much either, so we created installation, how-to and troubleshooting videos for every one of its major products, and in 90 days it owned that opening. Not every gap is an opportunity. But the right one, aligned with who you really are, can give you a real advantage.

And if it’s a position competitors could copy easily, move quickly and make it known before they catch up. Speed to market wins here.

Own an Opening You Can Prove

Own an opening in the brandscape: one your customers care about, your competitors can’t claim and you can prove today.

By Lori Turner-Wilson, RedRover CEO/Founder, Internationally Best-Selling Author of The B2B Marketing Revolution®: A Battle Plan for Guaranteed Outcomes

Taking Action

The above insights are part of hundreds of best practices found in The B2B Marketing Revolution®: A Battle Plan for Guaranteed Outcomes — the playbook that middle-market B2B CEOs and marketing leaders lean on to scale. Backed by a groundbreaking research study, this book offers time-tested best practices, indispensable KPIs for benchmarking, insights on where your dollars are best spent, and, above all, the proven 12 Battles™ Framework for generating guaranteed marketing outcomes. The B2B Marketing Revolution® is a battle-hardened approach to becoming an outcomes-first leader who’s ready to shake up the status quo, invest in high-payoff market research and optimization, and — yes — even torch what’s not serving your endgame. Download more than 50 templates, scripts, and tools from the book on the Battle Reader Hub.

If you’d like to talk about how to build a marketing engine that delivers predictable results — whether you want to build it yourself or tag in our team to lead the way — we’d be delighted to help you get started.

RedRover graphic with a dog at a laptop and the headline “What does AI say about you?”
What AI Tells Buyers About Your Company (and How to Check)Marketing Strategy

What AI Tells Buyers About Your Company (and How to Check)

AI answers vary, and a handful is a sample, not a verdict. Checking what AI…
RedRover graphic with a rising bar chart and the headline “The goldmine in your own sales data.”
Customer Transaction Analysis: The Untapped Goldmine in Your Own DataMarketing Strategy

Customer Transaction Analysis: The Untapped Goldmine in Your Own Data

Before you pay for new research, look at the research you already own. Your sales…
A red dart in a bullseye among dark darts beside the words “What your competitors can’t copy” and the RedRover logo.
How Optimization Turns Predictable Growth Into a Competitive AdvantageMarketing Strategy

How Optimization Turns Predictable Growth Into a Competitive Advantage

Small, cheap tests beat one big bet. Here’s how disciplined iteration compounds into the one…